We make thick, made to order milkshakes using our small batch, super premium ice cream and bold mix ins, served with playful, theatrical presentation at Brooker’s Founding Flavors Ice Cream in Herriman UT.
What our milkshakes include
Our milkshakes start with the same homemade, super premium ice cream that we scoop for sundaes and cakes. You choose a base flavor, then we mix in generous chunks, swirls and sauces to create a thick, spoonable shake. Options range from classic chocolate and vanilla to our more creative, chunky flavors. We offer single servings, thick malted shakes, and larger shareable shakes that are built for parties and celebrations.
Milkshakes are designed to be an experience for families, date nights, tourists and small events. Our tavern themed dining room and theatrical finishes make a milkshake more than a drink, it is a dessert moment that complements our made to order cakes and large format sundaes.
Benefits of choosing our milkshakes
- Small batch base. We use our homemade ice cream as the foundation for thicker texture and richer flavor.
- Generous mix ins. Large chunks and swirls make shakes more interesting to eat and share.
- Family friendly presentation. Theatrical plating and nostalgic tavern decor create a memorable treat for kids and adults.
- Portion variety. Single shakes, thick malts and large format shakes for groups are available.
- Pairs with desserts. Our shakes pair well with made to order cakes and large sundaes for celebrations.
How we make a milkshake
We follow a consistent process that keeps each milkshake thick, flavorful and camera ready. Our process balances quality ingredients with presentation so you get the taste you expect and the experience you planned.
- Choose a base flavor. Pick from our core menu of small batch ice cream flavors or ask about rotating specialties.
- Select mix ins and sauces. Add chunky cookies, candy pieces, fruit swirls or house made sauces. We recommend bold mix ins for thicker texture and added bite.
- Pick a style and size. Choose a classic single, a thick malted style, or a large format shake to share with a group.
- We blend and finish it. Our team blends the ingredients to preserve chunkiness, then finishes the shake with whipped cream, sauces and themed garnishes for presentation.
- Serve with care. Each shake is plated or handed over in a way that highlights the tavern aesthetic, so it is ready for a family photo or party moment.
Watch out: Thick, large format shakes are rich and intended for sharing. For young children, ask about smaller portions or a sample scoop instead of a full large shake.
What good milkshake work looks like
A well made milkshake from our shop has a dense, spoonable texture without tasting icy, generous visible mix ins, balanced sweetness, and a confident finish that matches the flavor on the menu. Presentation is tidy but playful, so the shake looks as good as it tastes and fits into a family outing or a small celebration.
If a shake is too thin, the balance is off and it will melt quickly. If it is overworked, the texture can become flat. Our team tunes blending time, portioning and mix in size to keep those tradeoffs in check.
Why choose Brooker’s Founding Flavors Ice Cream
We blend an Early American tavern atmosphere with modern, over the top dessert creativity. That combination shapes how we design milkshakes and other desserts. Families and event planners come for the theatrical presentation and the small batch recipes, while history buffs and tourists often mention the nostalgic decor as part of the experience.
Our focus is on high quality ingredients, bold mix ins, and generous portions. We also support local gatherings with large format desserts and made to order cakes when a party calls for a centerpiece dessert.
Service area
We regularly serve guests from Herriman and across the greater Salt Lake region. If you are planning a visit, know that families come from nearby cities for milkshakes and desserts.
- Herriman
- Salt Lake City
- South Salt Lake
- Draper
- Roy
- Ogden
- South Ogden
- West Haven
- Riverdale
- Layton
- Clearfield
- Syracuse
- North Salt Lake
- West Bountiful
- Bountiful
- Centerville
- Farmington
- Kaysville
- Layton Hills
- Pleasant View
- Fruit Heights
Related services and topics
Milkshakes pair naturally with our other offerings. Explore our ice cream menu to choose a base flavor, or browse milkshake inspiration on our milkshake styles page. For events and birthdays, see options for made to order cakes and large format desserts.
Frequently asked questions
Do you offer dairy free or alternative milk shakes?
We offer dairy free ice cream options at times. Availability varies by flavor, so ask at the counter or check our milkshake styles page for current dairy free choices.
Can I order a large format shake for a party?
Yes, we create larger shakes intended for sharing and celebration. For planning, review our large format desserts and cake options on the related services pages to pick a presentation that fits your event.
What sizes do your milkshakes come in?
Shakes are available in single serving sizes, thicker malt styles, and larger shareable sizes. Portion descriptions are posted at the shop and our team can explain which size works best for kids or groups.
Are there common allergens in your milkshakes?
Our milkshakes use ice cream, mix ins and sauces that commonly contain dairy, eggs, wheat, nuts and soy. If you have an allergy, tell us and we will take precautions, though cross contact is possible in a busy dessert kitchen.
Can you customize a shake with a specific candy or cookie?
We welcome custom mix in requests when the ingredient is available. For large group orders that require specific candy pieces, it is helpful to review options in advance on our cakes and large format desserts pages.
Where to learn more
Check Brooker’s Google Business Profile to read reviews and get directions, and stop by our Herriman shop to see the tavern themed presentation in person. For details about our hours and offerings, visit our Herriman location page and explore related topics on this site.